Choosing a pickup starts with one big question: how much truck do you actually need? At North Shore Chevrolet of Smithtown in St James, we sell both the midsize Chevrolet Colorado and the full-size Silverado 1500, so we see every day which size fits which driver. We'll start from the basics and build up, so no truck knowledge is required.
Colorado vs Silverado 1500: Truck Sizes Defined

Pickups come in size classes. A midsize truck like the Chevrolet Colorado is narrower and shorter than a full-size truck, yet it still has an open cargo bed and real truck hardware underneath. Step up to a full-size truck like the Silverado 1500 and you get a bigger, heavier vehicle. That "1500" marks it as the half-ton model, the lightest-duty member of the Silverado family.
A few more terms come up constantly:
- Cab: the passenger area. A crew cab has four full doors and a usable back seat.
- Bed: the open cargo box behind the cab.
- Trim: a version of the same truck with its own equipment and price.
- MSRP: the manufacturer's suggested retail price, before taxes, fees or discounts.
Why does size matter so much? It shapes how a truck parks, how it fits in a garage, what it costs to buy, and how much it can carry or pull. For most people around St James, the Colorado handles daily driving, weekend hauling and family duty in a package that's easier to live with. You can browse both trucks in our new truck inventory to see the size difference for yourself.
Colorado Power and Fuel Economy, Explained

Every Colorado trim uses the same 2.7 L 4-cylinder engine making 350 HP. For a first-time truck buyer, that's a real advantage. You don't have to decode an engine menu or pay extra for the stronger motor, because the strong motor comes standard.
2WD vs 4WD
Two-wheel drive (2WD) on the Colorado means rear-wheel drive, where the engine powers only the back wheels. Four-wheel drive (4WD) can send power to all four, which helps on snowy side streets, slick boat ramps and sandy beach access. Rear-wheel drive costs less and uses less fuel, with the 2WD trims rated 19 mpg city and 24 highway.
Where the Silverado 1500 fits
The Silverado 1500 offers a wider spread of engines, including V8 options, for owners who tow heavy loads often. A bigger truck also means hauling more of its own weight around on every trip. For commuting on the Northern State or Route 347 with occasional hauling, the Colorado's single strong engine is the simpler choice.
Colorado Trims, From WORK TRUCK to CREW CAB ZR2

Think of trims as steps on a ladder. Pricing starts at $33,500 for the WORK TRUCK (2WD) and climbs to $50,800 for the CREW CAB ZR2, and the engine stays the same the whole way up. What changes is equipment, comfort and off-road hardware.
- WORK TRUCK: the no-frills starting point, offered in 2WD or 4WD, built for jobs and tight budgets.
- CREW CAB LT: four full doors and more comfort features, also in 2WD or 4WD, a natural family pick.
- CREW CAB TRAIL BOSS: standard 4WD with a tougher, trail-ready setup for dirt roads and beach runs.
- CREW CAB Z71: 4WD with more off-road equipment and a step up in feel.
- CREW CAB ZR2: the most off-road-focused Colorado, with fuel economy of 16 mpg across the board as the trade-off.
Most North Shore families land on the CREW CAB LT or CREW CAB TRAIL BOSS. Either one gives you the back seat you need for kids or coworkers without paying for hardware you'll rarely use. Before you decide, check our current Colorado offers, since deals change from month to month.
Colorado vs Silverado 1500 on Long Island Roads
Size is where the Colorado earns its keep day to day. A narrower, shorter truck slips into tight spots at the Smithtown train station, handles the curves on Route 25A with ease, and has a better shot at fitting in an older Long Island garage. It also costs less up front than a full-size pickup, which can keep monthly payments easier to manage.
When a Silverado 1500 makes sense
Some drivers do need full-size. Pulling a large boat to the marina every weekend, hauling heavy equipment for work, or carrying adults in the back seat daily are jobs the Silverado 1500 is built to handle. Both trucks are Chevrolets, so you get the same support from us either way.
Here's an honest rule of thumb: buy for the hauling you do most weeks, not the one big job a year. Rent or borrow for the rare exception. Our team can walk you through financing options on either truck, with terms that depend on your credit and lender approval.
Test-Drive the Colorado at North Shore Chevrolet of Smithtown
Reading only gets you so far. Sitting in a Colorado, backing it into a space and taking it onto the highway tells you more in twenty minutes than any spec sheet. Bring your usual passengers, and if you tow, describe your trailer so we can talk it through.
What to check on your drive
- Visibility over the hood and around the bed when parking
- Back-seat room in the crew cab for your passengers
- How 2WD and 4WD trims feel on the same route
- Whether your gear fits the bed
After the sale, our GM factory-trained World Class and Master Class service technicians look after your truck, and our drive-in service lane keeps routine visits simple. We're involved in the community, with customer satisfaction as our top priority. When you're ready, book a Colorado test drive and we'll have one waiting.
St James, NY
- Buy for the hauling you do most weeks, and for most drivers that points to the Colorado.
- Every Colorado trim shares the same 2.7 L 4-cylinder, so you choose by equipment, not engine.
- The CREW CAB LT and CREW CAB TRAIL BOSS cover most family, beach and snow needs on the North Shore.